Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.4
Seveso III, reference texts and safety management
The Seveso Directive requires the most hazardous establishments to have a prevention policy, a safety management system, a hazard study and emergency plans.
French texts after 2003
| Text | Contribution |
|---|---|
| Law of 30 July 2003 (known as the Bachelot law) | Explicit definition of the hazard study; importance of risk analysis, preventive public information and control of urban development. |
| Order of 29 September 2005 amending article 4 of the Seveso order of 10 May 2000 (repealed and replaced by the order of 26 May 2014) | Major accident policy; cumulation rule modified (“toxic for the environment” criterion). |
| Order of 29 September 2005 (known as “PIG(C)”) | Assessment and consideration of the probability of occurrence, kinetics, intensity of effects and severity of consequences in hazard studies: probabilistic approach. |
| Circular of 29 September 2005 (known as “MMR”) | Criteria for assessing the risk control approach. |
| Circular of 7 October 2005 | Technological glossary. |
| Circular of 10 May 2010 | Methodological rules applicable to hazard studies and PPRT. |
The Seveso III Directive
- It applies to establishments, and no longer only to the classified installations of those establishments (which, under Seveso I, could exclude significant parts of an establishment).
- It distinguishes two categories: hazardous establishments (lower tier) and highly hazardous establishments (upper tier).
- Lower tier: the document defining the major accident prevention policy (MAPP, in French PPAM) is mandatory.
- Upper tier: in addition to the MAPP, a safety management system (SMS, in French SGS) integrated into the establishment’s management system.
The SMS defines the roles of personnel, the procedures and the resources that make it possible to define and implement the MAPP. It covers:
- organisation and training;
- identification and assessment of major accident risks;
- control of processes and operations;
- management of change;
- management of emergency situations;
- management of lessons learned;
- monitoring of the SMS through audits and management reviews.
Hazard study and emergency plans
Seveso establishments must have an in-depth hazard study setting out the risks incurred by the neighbourhood and the environment, the measures taken to reduce them and the residual risks. It covers all activities and presents the MAPP; for an upper-tier establishment, it also presents the SMS and is reviewed at least every 5 years.
| Plan | Who draws it up? | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| POI (on-site emergency plan) | The operator, under the supervision of the State and the fire and rescue services | Organisation of emergency response inside the plant; control of consequences within the establishment. |
| PPI (off-site emergency plan) | The prefect, based on the hazard study and the POI | Very serious accidents whose consequences extend beyond the plant: protection of populations and the environment. Required for highly hazardous sites. |
Internal and external emergency plans are reviewed regularly (at least every 3 years for the POI and PPI of upper-tier sites) and are the subject of exercises.
The Seveso order of 10 May 2000 is repealed: the reference text is the order of 26 May 2014. The DRIREs have become the DREALs (DRIEAT in Île-de-France), the regional environment authorities. Hazard study of upper-tier sites: review at least every 5 years (article R. 515-98 of the Environment Code). Emergency plans: POI and PPI of upper-tier sites reviewed at least every 3 years (Seveso III Directive, article 12; article R. 741-29 of the Internal Security Code). Since the reform launched after the Lubrizol fire (Rouen, 2019), the POI of upper-tier sites is also tested at least once a year.
Example: upper-tier Seveso sites around Grenoble
The Grenoble area has several upper-tier Seveso establishments, notably on the Jarrie and Pont-de-Claix chemical platforms, with varied main hazards (toxic, fire, explosion, radioactivity) and a risk zone perimeter ranging from a few hundred metres to 10 km.
| Company | Municipality | Main hazards | Perimeter of the risk zone |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arkema, Jarrie plant | Jarrie | Toxic, fire, explosion | 10,000 m |
| Cezus, Areva group | Jarrie | Toxic | 2,035 m |
| EPC France | Vif | Explosive | 2,100 m |
| Eurotungstène | Grenoble | Toxic, fire, explosion | 280 m |
| ILL | Grenoble | Radioactivity | 500 m |
| Isochem | Le Pont-de-Claix | Toxic, fire | 8,640 m |
| Sita Rekem | Le Pont-de-Claix | Toxic, fire | 0 m |
| Sobegal | Domène | Fire | 500 m |
| Stepan Europe | Voreppe | Toxic, fire | 280 m |
| Vencorex | Le Pont-de-Claix | Toxic | 10,000 m |
Safety management: a continuous improvement approach
Risk assessment is not an end in itself: its purpose lies in the prevention actions it prompts. Its aim is to implement an action plan to eliminate the risks that can be eliminated and reduce those that cannot, in order to keep the residual risk at an acceptable level.
1. Prepare the approach
2. Assess the risks
3. Plan the actions
4. Implement the actions
5. Reassess the risks, then start the cycle again.
Useful sources: the ARIA database of the Ministry of Ecological Transition (accident lessons learned), INERIS (studies and models), Légifrance (legal texts).
Seveso: lower tier = MAPP + hazard study; upper tier = in addition an SMS, a POI and a PPI. Safety is managed through a continuous improvement cycle whose goal is an acceptable residual risk.