Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.5
Operating risk: breakdowns, shutdowns and dependability
The previous lessons deal with major accidents, which are rare and very serious. Day to day, an industrial site mostly suffers breakdowns, shutdowns and limited accidents: this is the field of dependability.
- Distinguish major risk from operating risk
- Place safety and dependability
- Know which logic each analysis method serves
The facts: most of it is not major
In 2024, BARPI recorded 400 accidents and 829 incidents in classified installations, and no major accident within the meaning of the Seveso Directive. Lessons learned confirm this (lesson 2-3): internal property damage affects more than two thirds of accidents, production losses and temporary layoffs a significant share, while deaths remain around 2%. For a company, the most frequent risk is therefore loss of function: a pump that stops, a line that will not restart, an unavailable piece of equipment.
Two complementary logics
| Major accident (safety) | Operating risk (dependability) | |
|---|---|---|
| Frequency | Very low | High |
| Severity | Very high, beyond the site | Low to moderate, often limited to the site |
| Targets | People, neighbours, environment | Production, availability, quality, costs, sometimes staff |
| Feared event | Loss of containment, loss of control | Loss of function: breakdown, shutdown, drift |
| Framework | Regulatory (Seveso, hazard study) | Contractual, normative, economic |
The model is the same: a source of hazard, a flow, a target, damage. Only the target changes: here it is the function the system must provide (produce, transfer, heat) and the production that depends on it.
Safety and availability can conflict
A very safe system may be barely available: a safety shutdown protects people but stops production. Conversely, trying at all costs to avoid shutdowns can lead to bypassing a protection. Risk analysis must therefore look at both, and arbitrate. Dependability (reliability, maintainability, availability, safety) provides the vocabulary and the calculations for this: it is detailed in chapter 4.
Which method for which logic?
- The PHA (chapter 6) identifies hazards and feared events early, major and operating alike.
- The FMEA (chapter 7) examines the failure modes of components and their effects: it is the natural tool of dependability.
- The HAZOP (chapter 8) looks for process deviations, which lead to a breakdown as well as to an accident.
- The fault tree and the bow-tie (chapters 9 and 10) quantify scenarios, from the most common to the rarest.
Industrial risk includes major risk (rare, very serious, regulated) and operating risk (frequent, more limited, linked to loss of function). Safety and availability are two objectives that can conflict; dependability (chapter 4) makes it possible to assess them together.