Aurorisk FR

Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.4

STPA at a glance and the Vauclair case

STPA (System-Theoretic Process Analysis) is the hazard analysis method based on STAMP. It follows four steps, taken up in chapters 2 to 4, on a running case presented here.

The four steps

StepQuestionResultChapter
1. Define the purpose of the analysisWhich losses to avoid? Which system hazards cause them?Losses, hazards, system safety constraints2
2. Model the control structureWho controls what, with which commands and which feedback?Diagram of the control loops2
3. Identify unsafe control actionsWhich command, given or not, in which context, leads to a hazard?List of UCAs, controller constraints3
4. Identify loss scenariosWhy could a UCA occur? Why could a correct command not be executed?Scenarios, requirements, measures4

The method starts before the design is frozen: it is used to derive requirements. It also applies to an existing plant to review its safety.

The running case: the unloading station of the Vauclair depot

The Vauclair depot is fictitious, as are all the figures. It stores a flammable solvent in a 40 m³ tank T1. Tanker trucks are unloaded at the unloading station.

ElementRole
Unloading operatorChecks the delivery note, the hose connection and the earthing, checks the available room in T1, starts and monitors the unloading, can stop it
Unloading PLCOpens the inlet valve XV1 and starts pump P1 after the start command; closes XV1 and stops P1 at the high level (85% of T1, example assumption)
Level sensor LT1Continuously measures the level of T1 for the PLC and the operator’s screen
Safety instrumented system (SIS)Receives a very-high level detector LSHH (92%, example assumption), closes XV1 and stops P1, independently of the PLC
Site managerSets the instructions, the procedures and the rules for assigning products to tanks
The unloading station of the Vauclair depotThe tanker truck is connected by an earthed hose to pump P1, then to valve XV1 and to the 40 cubic metre tank T1. The PLC, started by the operator, controls P1 and XV1 from level transmitter LT1 and stops at the high level of 85 percent. The independent SIS receives the very high level detector LSHH at 92 percent and closes XV1.OperatorPLCSISTanker truckHose, earthedP1XV1T1 (40 m³)LSHH 92%High 85%LT1level
The unloading station (fictional case). The PLC and the SIS both act on XV1 and P1; each has its own level sensor. Dotted lines: command and measurement links.

Since the equipment is reliable and partly redundant, the question is not only “what happens if XV1 stays open?” but “in which situations does giving or not giving each command lead to a spill or to the wrong product in the tank?”.

Key takeaways
  • STPA follows four steps: purpose, control structure, unsafe control actions, loss scenarios.
  • The Vauclair case is used in the following chapters: one operator, one PLC, one SIS, one pump, one valve, one tank.