Aurorisk FR

Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.3

STAMP: safety as a control problem

STAMP (Systems-Theoretic Accident Model and Processes) is an accident model proposed by Nancy Leveson (MIT). It replaces the question “which component failed?” with “which safety constraint was not enforced?”.

Three ideas

  1. Constraints. Safety is a property of the system: it is maintained by enforcing constraints (“the product stays in the circuit”, “two incompatible products are never brought into contact”). An accident occurs when these constraints are not respected.
  2. Control. Constraints are enforced by hierarchical control loops: a controller (PLC, operator, site manager, regulation) acts on a process and receives feedback.
  3. Process model. To control, every controller holds a model of the state of the process. If this model diverges from reality, decisions become dangerous.
Basic control loopA controller, which contains a process model, sends control actions to an actuator; the actuator acts on the controlled process; a sensor sends information back to the controller.ControllerProcess modelActuatorSensorControlled processControl actionEffect on theprocessMeasurementsFeedback
A control loop: the controller acts according to the model it has of the process, and this model is updated by feedback.

What this changes

QuestionCausal chain modelSTAMP
Nature of a causeFailure, errorConstraint not enforced
Role of the operatorSource of error to be framedController whose decision depends on their model and on the information received
SoftwareComponent that can failController whose algorithm may be inappropriate
OrganisationRemote causeHigher control level, with its own constraints and feedback
Definition

An unsafe control action (UCA) is a command that, in a given context, leads to a system hazard. It is the central object of the STPA method.

References: N. Leveson, Engineering a Safer World, MIT Press, 2011; N. Leveson and J. Thomas, STPA Handbook, MIT, 2018 (freely available). STAMP has also given an accident analysis method, CAST, presented in the course Accident analysis and lessons learned.

Key takeaways
  • STAMP sees an accident as the result of constraints not enforced by control loops.
  • Every controller acts according to a process model; a wrong model is a cause of accident in its own right.