Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.8
Monitoring, indicators, operating experience and safety culture
A risk that is under control today is not necessarily so tomorrow: ageing barriers, procedures that are bypassed, organisation that changes. Monitoring and review keep the calculations true over time.
Updated: October 2026. Sources: text of ISO 31000:2018, 6.6 and 6.7; HSE (HSG254); API RP 754; IOGP (report 456); Baker Panel (January 2007); INERIS (SMS).
Monitoring and review (6.6)
- Monitoring : continuously detect deviations from the expected performance. Review : check that the arrangements remain suitable and effective.
- Purpose : check that controls work, learn lessons from events, detect changes in context and emerging risks.
- Means : management review, regular inspections, internal and external audits, indicator tracking, document control, operating experience feedback. Monitoring takes place at every step of the process.
Recording and reporting (6.7)
The process and its outcomes are documented and communicated to inform decisions, improve activities and support interaction with stakeholders. In France, the safety report, the on-site emergency plan, SMS audit reports and accident and incident declarations are the regulatory records.
Indicators: leading and lagging
| Lagging indicators (lagging) | Leading indicators (leading) | |
|---|---|---|
| What they measure | The outcomes : events that have already occurred. | Thestate of the controls, before the event. |
| Examples | Losses of containment; lost-time accidents (frequency rate); fires and explosions; accidental releases; cost of damage. | Maintenance backlog on safety-critical equipment; share of barriers tested on schedule; active bypasses; corrective actions closed on time; emergency drills carried out; near misses reported and analysed. |
| Advantage | Objective, unambiguous. | Allow action before the accident. |
| Limit | Arrive too late; few in number for rare major accidents. | Harder to select; link with the risk has to be demonstrated. |
- HSE (HSG254) : select the major risks, identify the risk control systems, then associate with each one a lagging indicator and one or more leading indicators (“dual assurance”).
- API RP 754 (2010): four tiers, from most lagging to most leading: tiers 1 and 2 for losses of containment (public comparisons), tiers 3 and 4 for challenges to safety systems and operational discipline (internal use). IOGP (report 456) and CCPS propose consistent approaches.
- Warning (Baker Panel, 2007) : after the explosion at the BP Texas City refinery (23 March 2005, fifteen dead), the panel found that BP had taken the improvement in its occupational accident rates as proof that process safety was under control; individual injury rates do not predict process safety.
- Pitfalls : too many indicators; a target that discourages reporting (a near-miss indicator must not be penalised); indicators unrelated to the major scenarios; no action threshold.
Examples of indicators for Val-des-Pins
| Control | Leading indicator | Lagging indicator |
|---|---|---|
| Safety barriers (SIS, relief valves) | % of periodic tests done on schedule; number of active bypasses | Number of failures revealed on demand or during tests |
| Maintenance | Preventive maintenance backlog on safety-critical equipment (in days or number of work orders) | Number of losses of containment |
| Loading | % of drivers trained; deviations found in station audits | Number of leaks at the loading station |
| Emergency | Emergency drills carried out / planned; response time | Gap observed during a real event |
| Culture | Near misses reported and analysed; corrective actions closed on time | Lost-time accidents |
Operating experience and safety culture
- The operating experience feedback turns events (one’s own and those of others, for example the ARIA database) into actions: analysis, causal tree, action plan, tracked closure.
- The safety culture (principle g): how the organisation’s values, behaviours and priorities deal with safety; it is judged by decisions when production and safety conflict, by how bad news is escalated, by a spirit of vigilance. ICSI and FonCSI publish guides on the subject.
- The audits of the SMS and the management review close the loop: resource decisions, revision of the criteria, update of the safety report.