Aurorisk FR

Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.8

Monitoring, indicators, operating experience and safety culture

A risk that is under control today is not necessarily so tomorrow: ageing barriers, procedures that are bypassed, organisation that changes. Monitoring and review keep the calculations true over time.

Lagging and leading indicatorsLagging: Events that have already occurred; Losses of containment, accidents; Objective but late — Leading: State of the controls; Barriers tested, maintenance up to date; Allow action beforeLaggingEvents that have already occurredLosses of containment,accidentsObjective but lateLeadingState of the controlsBarriers tested,maintenance up to dateAllow action before
After Texas City (2005), the occupational accident rate is not enough to track major risk.

Updated: October 2026. Sources: text of ISO 31000:2018, 6.6 and 6.7; HSE (HSG254); API RP 754; IOGP (report 456); Baker Panel (January 2007); INERIS (SMS).

Monitoring and review (6.6)

Recording and reporting (6.7)

The process and its outcomes are documented and communicated to inform decisions, improve activities and support interaction with stakeholders. In France, the safety report, the on-site emergency plan, SMS audit reports and accident and incident declarations are the regulatory records.

Indicators: leading and lagging

Lagging indicators (lagging)Leading indicators (leading)
What they measureThe outcomes : events that have already occurred.Thestate of the controls, before the event.
ExamplesLosses of containment; lost-time accidents (frequency rate); fires and explosions; accidental releases; cost of damage.Maintenance backlog on safety-critical equipment; share of barriers tested on schedule; active bypasses; corrective actions closed on time; emergency drills carried out; near misses reported and analysed.
AdvantageObjective, unambiguous.Allow action before the accident.
LimitArrive too late; few in number for rare major accidents.Harder to select; link with the risk has to be demonstrated.

Examples of indicators for Val-des-Pins

ControlLeading indicatorLagging indicator
Safety barriers (SIS, relief valves)% of periodic tests done on schedule; number of active bypassesNumber of failures revealed on demand or during tests
MaintenancePreventive maintenance backlog on safety-critical equipment (in days or number of work orders)Number of losses of containment
Loading% of drivers trained; deviations found in station auditsNumber of leaks at the loading station
EmergencyEmergency drills carried out / planned; response timeGap observed during a real event
CultureNear misses reported and analysed; corrective actions closed on timeLost-time accidents

Operating experience and safety culture

Hands-on: classify and choose indicators