Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.7
Risk treatment: seven options and a plan
Treating risk means choosing options, planning them, checking that they work, then deciding whether the remaining risk is acceptable. Treatment can itself create risks.
Updated: October 2026. Sources: text of ISO 31000:2018, 6.5; ISO 45001:2018 (hierarchy of controls, from the publisher’s pages).
An iterative process (6.5.1)
- Formulate and select risk treatment options;
- plan and implement the treatment;
- assess its effectiveness;
- decide whether the residual risk is acceptable ;
- if not, treat further.
The seven options (6.5.2)
| Option | Meaning | Example (Val-des-Pins) |
|---|---|---|
| Avoid | Decide not to start or not to continue the activity that gives rise to the risk. | Give up a railcar unloading station close to housing. |
| Take or increase the risk | To pursue an opportunity. | Increase storage capacity for a new contract: requires a new assessment and new criteria. |
| Remove the risk source | Eliminate the hazard at its root (inherent safety). | Reduce the stored inventory; replace a tank with underground or mounded storage. |
| Change the likelihood | Prevention: act on the probability of the event. | Add a very-high-level SIS, a fail-safe valve; strengthen maintenance and inspections. |
| Change the consequences | Protection: limit the intensity or severity. | Mound, sphere water spray, gas detection and emergency shutdown, limits on urban development (PPRT). |
| Share the risk | Contracts, insurance. | Property damage insurance; clauses with the carrier. This reduces neither the probability nor the human consequences. |
| Retain the risk | Informed decision (“accept”). | Residual risk of very low probability judged acceptable, recorded and monitored. |
The options are not mutually exclusive and are not appropriate in all circumstances. The choice balances the expected benefits for the objectives against the costs, effort or drawbacks; the justification is broader than economic : obligations, voluntary commitments, stakeholders’ views.
Mapping to barriers and LOPA : prevention barriers act on likelihood, protection barriers on consequences; LOPA adds independent protection layers until the tolerable frequency gap is closed (course “Barriers, LOPA and quantification”, chapter 1). In the classic hierarchy of prevention (eliminate, substitute, protect collectively, organise, protect individually), removing the source comes before the added barrier.
The treatment plan (6.5.3)
It says how and in what order the options will be implemented: justification, owners, actions, resources, performance measures, monitoring and deadlines.
| Action | Owner | Resources | Performance measure | Deadline |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Very-high-level SIS on tanks | Instrumentation manager | Capital budget | Test completion rate on schedule; PFD verified | Annual maintenance shutdown |
| Fail-safe valves on loading arms | Operations manager | Supplier, station shutdown | Bypass rate: zero | Next quarter |
Illustrative example of a plan (fictitious values).
When the risk remains too high, or when there is no option
- If no option is available or if the options do not change the risk enough, the risk should be recorded and kept under permanent review.
- If the residual risk remains intolerable: further treatment, or reconsidering the objectives (even to the point of giving up the activity).
- Between acceptable and intolerable, the intermediate zone is dealt with by ALARP logic (as low as reasonably practicable): reduce the risk until the cost is clearly disproportionate.
Even when carefully designed, treatments may not produce the expected results and may cause unintended consequences: a SIS that trips too often multiplies shutdowns and restarts, which are themselves accident-prone; a barrier bypassed for convenience becomes a false sense of safety. Monitoring is an integral part of implementing the treatment.