Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.9
From calculation to management: safety report, PPRT, LOPA and ISO 31000
The other courses (Safety report, Industrial risks, “Barriers, LOPA and quantification”) provide calculation and decision tools. ISO 31000 explains how to hold them together, over time, with responsibilities.
Updated: October 2026. Sources: text of ISO 31000:2018; courses Safety report, Industrial risks and “Barriers, LOPA and quantification”; links proposed for teaching purposes, with no regulatory value.
Liquefied petroleum gas (propane) depot entirely fictitious : four horizontal cylindrical tanks, a tanker-truck loading point, a rail-wagon unloading point, a fire-water network, and the first houses a few hundred metres away. The figures are teaching assumptions, with no regulatory value.
Where does each tool fit in the process?
| Tool | ISO 31000 step | Role for Val-des-Pins |
|---|---|---|
| Safety report (course Safety report, ch. 1) | Assessment + recording and reporting + demonstration of control | Regulatory document that brings together scenarios, rating, measures and justification. |
| PPRT (course Safety report, ch. 2) | Risk treatment (control of urban development, land measures) + communication and consultation | Reduce the consequences for local residents when the operator cannot reduce them alone; decisions reached through consultation. |
| PHA (course Safety report, ch. 3) | Identification | List of candidate scenarios. |
| Detailed analysis : probability, intensity, severity (course Safety report, ch. 4) | Analysis | Risk level of each major scenario. |
| Barriers, SIS and SIL (course “Barriers, LOPA and quantification”, ch. 1; Functional safety: SIS and SIL) | Analysis of controls + treatment (likelihood, consequences) | Effectiveness of barriers; choice of integrity level. |
| LOPA (course “Barriers, LOPA and quantification”, ch. 1) | Evaluation (comparison with the tolerable frequency gap) + choice of treatment | How many independent protection layers are needed? |
| ISO 31000 (this course) | Principles, framework, criteria, monitoring, review, culture | Who decides, with what criteria, and how do we know it holds? |
The running case, end to end
- Framework : the manager adopts the prevention policy, appoints an owner for each major scenario, allocates the barrier maintenance budget.
- Criteria : regulatory (2005 order grid) and internal (more demanding).
- Identification : PHA and HAZOP; scenarios S1 BLEVE, S2 leak at loading, S3 overfilling, S4 flange leak…
- Analysis : probability, intensity, severity with their uncertainties; existing barriers and their PFD.
- Assessment : S1 and S3 exceed the criterion: LOPA shows a shortfall of one protection layer.
- Treatment : an independent SIS; a mound; inventory reduction; for local residents, PPRT measures. The residual risk is then evaluated.
- Monitoring : periodic tests, maintenance backlog, bypasses, near misses, SMS audits. Management review: update of the safety report, the criteria and the controls.
What management adds to calculation
PFDs and frequencies assume that tests are done on time and barriers are available. Without monitoring, the calculation becomes wrong without anyone knowing.
A risk value is not a decision. The criteria, the risk owner and validation by management make it executable.
Probability values are orders of magnitude; methods must be combined, assumptions made explicit and weak signals monitored.
Organisational barriers and behaviour (bypassing, pressure, vigilance) weigh as much as technical barriers.
Local residents, employees, the authorities, insurers: consultation, transparency, acceptability.
Operating experience and audits feed the revision of the safety report, the criteria and the framework.
Checklist
- Were the risk criteria set before the analysis and validated by management?
- Does each major scenario have an owner, identified barriers and indicators?
- Are the LOPA reliability assumptions followed up (tests, maintenance, bypasses)?
- Are deviations and events escalated, analysed, closed out ?
- Have the stakeholders concerned been informed and consulted ?
- Does the management review update the safety report, the criteria and the controls?
The safety report answers “ where does the risk stand? ”, the PPRT “ what do we do for third parties? ”, LOPA “ are the barriers enough? ”. ISO 31000 answers “ how do we make sure, over time, that these answers remain true and that they are decided by those who must answer for them? ».