Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.5
Scope, context and risk criteria
Before assessing a risk, you must say what you are talking about and and at what point a risk is acceptable. Risk criteria are set before the analysis, not after.
Updated: October 2026. Sources: text of ISO 31000:2018, 5.4.1 and 6.3; scales of the order of 29 September 2005.
Liquefied petroleum gas (propane) depot entirely fictitious : four horizontal cylindrical tanks, a tanker-truck loading point, a rail-wagon unloading point, a fire-water network, and the first houses a few hundred metres away. The figures are teaching assumptions, with no regulatory value.
Define the scope (6.3.2)
Specify the objectives and decisions concerned, what is included or excluded, the resources, the responsibilities and the records expected.
- Val-des-Pins : the depot’s safety report (storage, loading, unloading, utilities). Excluded: transport beyond the site boundary (dealt with elsewhere). Decision expected: acceptability of the major scenarios and the programme of measures.
Understand the contexts (5.4.1 and 6.3.3)
| External context (examples from the standard) | Internal context (examples from the standard) |
|---|---|
| Social, cultural, political, legal, regulatory, financial, technological, economic and environmental factors; trends; relationships, perceptions and expectations of external stakeholders; contractual commitments; networks and dependencies. | Vision, mission, values; governance, structure, roles; strategy, objectives, policies; culture; standards and models adopted; capabilities (resources, knowledge); information systems; internal stakeholders; interdependencies. |
| Val-des-Pins : Seveso and PPRT regulations, residents, firefighters, hauliers, customers, insurers. | Val-des-Pins : prevention policy, staffing, subcontracting of loading, age of equipment, safety culture. |
Define the risk criteria (6.3.4)
The organisation specifies the amount and type of risk it may or may not take in relation to its objectives, and the criteria used to judge the significance of a risk. They reflect its values, objectives, resources, obligations and the views of stakeholders. They are established at the outset, then reviewed if necessary. They say how consequences and likelihoodare measured, how the level of risk is determined, and how to handle combinations of risks.
In French industrial safety, some of the criteria are imposed : the order of 29 September 2005 (probability, kinetics, intensity of effects and severity of consequences in safety reports) defines probability classes (from E to A) and severity classes (from “moderate” to “disastrous”, in number of people exposed within the effect zones) and a decision matrix. The operator may add stricter criteria: acceptability thresholds of an industrial group, frequency gap tolerated in a LOPA (Industrial Risks 2 course, chapter 1), insurer requirements.
Probability classes are powers of ten: moving from one class to the next multiplies or divides by a factor of about ten. Adding the probability and severity ranks therefore amounts to multiplying orders of magnitude: this is what the tool below does to draw an acceptability boundary.
Criteria and objectives: do not set them after the fact
- Setting the criteria before the analysis avoids adjusting the threshold to the desired result.
- Criteria that are consistent : at equal severity, a more probable risk cannot be judged more acceptable; at equal probability, neither can a more serious one.
- Criteria must be communicated (consultation) and validated at the right level: the acceptability threshold is a management decision.