Aurorisk FR

Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.3

Low demand, high demand and SIL levels

The reliability level of a SIF is not measured the same way depending on whether it is called on rarely or often. Two operating modes are therefore distinguished, and for each, four SIL levels.

Two modes

Low demand

The function is called on rarely, at most once a year. This is the usual case in the process industry: the drum SIF is only demanded if the gas outlet is blocked.

Quantity used: the PFDavg, the average probability that it fails to respond when demanded.

High demand or continuous mode

The function is called on more than once a year, or acts permanently (stopping a press at each cycle, a brake).

Quantity used: the PFH, the average frequency of dangerous failure per hour.

The four SIL levels

SILLow demand: PFDavgRisk reduction (1/PFD)High demand: PFH (per hour)
4from 10-5 to less than 10-4more than 10,000 to 100,000from 10-9 to less than 10-8
3from 10-4 to less than 10-3more than 1,000 to 10,000from 10-8 to less than 10-7
2from 10-3 to less than 10-2more than 100 to 1,000from 10-7 to less than 10-6
1from 10-2 to less than 10-1more than 10 to 100from 10-6 to less than 10-5
The four SIL bands in low demandLogarithmic scale of PFDavg from 10 to the minus 5 to 10 to the minus 1, divided into four bands of a factor of 10: SIL 4, SIL 3, SIL 2, SIL 1. Above, the corresponding risk reduction, from 100,000 to 10. SIF-201, at 1.26 times 10 to the minus 3, lies in the SIL 2 band.Risk reduction (1/PFD)SIL 4SIL 3SIL 2SIL 110⁻⁵10⁻⁴10⁻³10⁻²10⁻¹100,00010,0001,00010010SIF-201: 1.26·10⁻³PFDavg
Each band covers a factor of 10. The further left, the more reliable the function must be. The SIF of the case, at 1.26·10⁻³, is in the SIL 2 band.

Each level corresponds to a factor of 10. A SIL 2 SIF in low demand must therefore respond at least 99 times out of 100 on average; a SIL 3, at least 999 times out of 1,000.

SIL is not just a number

Reaching the right PFDavg is not enough: architectural constraints (minimum redundancy) and a systematic capability (quality of design and development) must also be met. These three conditions are detailed in chapter 5.

SIL belongs to the function

People often speak of a “SIL 2 sensor” or a “SIL 3 valve”. This is a shortcut: a component has failure rates and a capability (it is “usable up to SIL 2” under certain conditions), but it is the complete function, with its architecture, tests and maintenance, that reaches a SIL or not.

In practice, the process industry most often limits its SIFs to SIL 3. A need for SIL 4 is generally a sign that the design should be reviewed or other layers added.

Key takeaway
  • Low demand (at most once a year): PFDavg; high demand or continuous: PFH.
  • Four SILs, a factor of 10 per level: SIL 2 = PFDavg from 10⁻³ to less than 10⁻².
  • SIL belongs to the complete function, not to a component.