Aurorisk FR

Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.3

The six steps of LOPA

The method runs in six steps, the first two relying on the preliminary hazard analysis and the bow-tie.

The six steps of LOPAScenario selection criteria; Scenario development; Frequency of initiating events; Identification of IPLs and their PFDs; Calculation of the risk level; Risk treatment1. Scenario selection criteria2. Scenario development3. Frequency of initiating events4. Identification of IPLs and theirPFD5. Risk level calculation6. Risk treatment
One initiating event, one consequence.
  1. Scenario selection criteria : for example, all scenarios whose severity exceeds a given threshold (serious injuries, deaths, off-site impact).
  2. Scenario development : one initiating event, one consequence, the existing barriers (preliminary hazard analysis, bow-tie).
  3. Frequency of initiating events (per year).
  4. Identification of IPLs and their PFDs.
  5. Calculation of the risk level (frequency of the final event).
  6. Risk evaluation and treatment to be carried out.

Step 3: initiating events

The frequencies come from databases, operating experience and expert opinion. Orders of magnitude commonly quoted in the LOPA literature: failure of the basic process control system (BPCS) of the order of 0.1 per year; operator error on a single task from 0.01 to 0.1 per year; failure of a control valve of the order of 0.1 per year; external impact of the order of 10−3 per year. In a study, they are replaced by site data where these exist, and each value retained is justified.

Step 4: identify the IPLs

  1. Identify the existing barriers, from upstream to downstream: (1) design, construction, training, maintenance, inspection, drills; (2) control systems and supervision by operators; (3) safety alarms and operator intervention; (4) automatic safety systems; (5) ultimate safeguards; (6) on-site then off-site emergency plans; (7) land-use planning; (8) public information and the off-site emergency plan.
  2. Check that these barriers are independent of one another.
  3. Assess the probability of failure on demand of each.

Step 5: calculation

The frequency of the final event is the product of the initiator frequency by the PFDs of all the IPLs and, where applicable, by conditional factors :

These factors often change the conclusion by a decade. They must be justified and are not barriers: they describe the scenario, they do not prevent it.

Formula

Fc = FIE × PFD1 × PFD2 × PFD3 × …

Step 6: treat

F is comparedc with the risk target associated with the severity; the gap gives the reduction factor and the level of the barriers to add (lesson 1-6).