Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.3
The six steps of LOPA
The method runs in six steps, the first two relying on the preliminary hazard analysis and the bow-tie.
- Scenario selection criteria : for example, all scenarios whose severity exceeds a given threshold (serious injuries, deaths, off-site impact).
- Scenario development : one initiating event, one consequence, the existing barriers (preliminary hazard analysis, bow-tie).
- Frequency of initiating events (per year).
- Identification of IPLs and their PFDs.
- Calculation of the risk level (frequency of the final event).
- Risk evaluation and treatment to be carried out.
Step 3: initiating events
The frequencies come from databases, operating experience and expert opinion. Orders of magnitude commonly quoted in the LOPA literature: failure of the basic process control system (BPCS) of the order of 0.1 per year; operator error on a single task from 0.01 to 0.1 per year; failure of a control valve of the order of 0.1 per year; external impact of the order of 10−3 per year. In a study, they are replaced by site data where these exist, and each value retained is justified.
Step 4: identify the IPLs
- Identify the existing barriers, from upstream to downstream: (1) design, construction, training, maintenance, inspection, drills; (2) control systems and supervision by operators; (3) safety alarms and operator intervention; (4) automatic safety systems; (5) ultimate safeguards; (6) on-site then off-site emergency plans; (7) land-use planning; (8) public information and the off-site emergency plan.
- Check that these barriers are independent of one another.
- Assess the probability of failure on demand of each.
Step 5: calculation
The frequency of the final event is the product of the initiator frequency by the PFDs of all the IPLs and, where applicable, by conditional factors :
- enabling conditions : the scenario is only possible part of the time (start-up phase, season, product present only a few weeks a year);
- probability of ignition of a flammable release, which depends on the flow rate and the ignition sources;
- probability of presence of a person in the effects zone, and the probability that the exposure is fatal.
These factors often change the conclusion by a decade. They must be justified and are not barriers: they describe the scenario, they do not prevent it.
Fc = FIE × PFD1 × PFD2 × PFD3 × …
Step 6: treat
F is comparedc with the risk target associated with the severity; the gap gives the reduction factor and the level of the barriers to add (lesson 1-6).