Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.2
Principle and objectives of LOPA
LOPA (Layer of Protection Analysis) is a method semi-quantitative that assesses, scenario by scenario, whether the barriers in place are enough to bring the risk down to the target level.
Chapter objectives
- Carry out a LOPA, scenario by scenario
- Judge the independence of protection layers
- Derive the SIL of a barrier to be added
Origin and characteristics
- Developed in the 1990s by the CCPS (Center for Chemical Process Safety); the reference book, Layer of Protection Analysis : Simplified Process Risk Assessment, dates from 2001.
- It is applied after a qualitative risk identification method (HAZOP, preliminary hazard analysis, bow-tie), which it complements.
- It reasons in orders of magnitude: frequencies, probabilities and severity levels are rounded to powers of 10.
Two validity rules
- domino effect a single scenario at a time, from one initiating cause to one consequence.
- The barriers assessed are independent of one another: this is the assumption at the heart of the method.
Objectives
- Judge the adequacy of the barriers in place for the level of risk;
- Decide on implementing new barriers, with minimum requirements on the probability of failure (hence the SIL for an SIS);
- Assess the residual frequency of occurrence of the accident scenario.
Vocabulary
| Acronym | Meaning |
|---|---|
| SIL | Safety integrity level (Safety Integrity Level), linked to the probability of failure |
| SIF | Safety instrumented function (Safety Instrumented Function) |
| IPL | Independent protection layer (Independent Protection Layer) |
| PFD | Probability of failure on demand (Probability of Failure on Demand) |
Link with the bow-tie
A bow-tie can generate several LOPA analysis lines, one per cause-consequence pair. The most severe consequence is retained. All the cause branches on the left of the top event can be grouped, but the initiating frequency is then higher; if the causes are independent, separating the scenarios can lead to barriers with a lower confidence level.
LOPA fits into the ISO 31000 risk management approach as a tool for risk assessment and treatment.