Aurorisk FR

Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.4

Independent protection layers (IPL) and their PFDs

An IPL is a safety barrier able, on its own, to stop the scenario from reaching its consequence, and independent of the initiating event and of the other layers. It can be technical, organisational or human.

Onion-skin protection layers around a scenario Seven concentric circles numbered from the outside to the inside: off-site emergency plans, on-site emergency plan, physical protections, safety instrumented systems, alarms and operator intervention, control system, process design, with the scenario at the centre. 7654321 Scenario 7 Off-site emergency plans (PPI) 6 On-site emergency plan (POI) 5 Physical protections 4 Safety instrumented (SIS) 3 Alarms and operators 2 Control system (BPCS) 1 Process design

The inner layers prevent the event, the outer layers limit its consequences: an outer layer does not reduce the frequency of the top event, it limits its severity.

Criteria for a barrier to be an IPL

Usual PFD values

IPLUsual PFD
Control loop (BPCS)10−1
Operator response to an alarm10−1
Safety valve10−2
Well-designed pressure vessel10−4 (or better depending on maintenance)
SIS10−1 à 10−4 depending on the SIL (PFD calculationavg)

In the LOPA literature (CCPS 2001, relayed by secondary summaries), the orders of magnitude are 0.1 for an operator response within 30 minutes with alarm and training, 0.1 for the BPCS, 0.01 for a correctly sized safety valve (possible range of 10−1 à 10−5 depending on service conditions), and 10−2 à 10−4 for a SIL 1 to 3 SIS. Each value credited in a study must be justified: design, tests, maintenance and operating experience of the barrier.

Direct calculation for an SIS

PFDavg = λDU · TI / 2 (see lesson 4-2 of the course on SIS and SIL); the value obtained is interpreted via the SIL (SIL 1 to 4).

Pitfalls

Two barriers that rely on the same sensor are not independent. An alarm followed by an operator action is a single IPL, not two. An IPL must be in working order when called upon (tests, maintenance, bypasses).