Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.1
What is an industrial risk?
A company is exposed to many risks, physical or not. Industrial risk covers accidents, breakdowns and shutdowns of installations. It is called major when its consequences extend beyond the company: they reach staff, neighbours, property and the environment.
- Define major industrial risk and operating risk
- Describe the three types of effects of a major accident
- Place the four pillars of French policy and the role of the hazard study
- Distinguish the obligations of lower-tier and upper-tier Seveso establishments
Controlling risks: why and how?
Throughout its existence, a company is subject to risks affecting its physical components (people, installations, machines) as well as its non-physical ones (results, the very existence of the company). Examples range from commercial, legal or financial risk to health, fire, cyberattack or breakdown risk. The aim is not to reach “zero risk”, which does not exist, but to control risks: to know them, assess them and bring them down to an acceptable level.
This course aims at the ability to know and apply risk analysis methods for industrial systems: dependability studies and hazard studies. It relies on examples and a case study.
The basic model: hazardous phenomenon, target, damage
A risk is described as a chain: a hazardous phenomenon (explosion, fire, toxic leak, failure, etc.) reaches a vulnerable target (population, users, natural environment, installations) and produces damage (harm to the population, pollution, breakdowns, destruction). The occurrence of the risk corresponds to the occurrence of the degradation phenomenon.
Two notions: major industrial risk and operating risk
On an industrial site, an accidental event or a breakdown does not always have the same reach. Two notions are distinguished:
An accidental event that can occur on an industrial site handling dangerous products or processes, and leading to serious immediate consequences for staff, neighbours, property and the environment.
An accident, incident or breakdown affecting a workstation, a machine or a technical system, whose consequences remain limited, most often to the site itself: harm to production, to equipment, sometimes to staff. It is far more frequent than major risk.
Both follow the same model (hazardous phenomenon, target, damage); they differ in severity, frequency and the reach of their consequences. Lessons 1-2 to 1-4 deal with major risk and its regulation; lesson 1-5 compares the two and introduces dependability.
Technological risks in four categories
- Industrial risks on site (in 2024, BARPI, the French accident analysis bureau, recorded 400 accidents and 829 incidents in classified installations, and no major accident within the meaning of the Seveso Directive);
- transport of dangerous goods (TDG);
- Natech risks: technological accidents triggered by a natural phenomenon (flood, lightning, earthquake, heatwave). With climate change, these hazards are becoming more frequent and more intense: the hazard study must examine their effect on the installations (pumps submerged, loss of cooling, lightning strike on a tank);
- nuclear risk.
What happens during an industrial accident?
Historical statistics from the ARIA database (1992-2004) cover all recorded accidents, major or not, and give the breakdown of event types; recent annual BARPI inventories confirm that fires and releases of dangerous substances predominate:
| Type of event | Year 2003 (%) | 1992 to 2004 (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Fires | 58 | 52 |
| Releases of dangerous substances | 37 | 45 |
| Explosions | 5.2 | 5.4 |
| Domino effects | 3.9 | 2.7 |
| Projectiles, falling equipment | 2.1 | 2.5 |
| Near misses | 1.9 | 2.0 |
| Aggravated chronic pollution | 0.4 | 1.5 |
| BLEVE | 0.1 | 0.1 |
| Irradiation | 0.4 | 0.2 |
The percentages do not add up to 100: a single accident can combine several types of events.
Major industrial hazard = a hazardous phenomenon of industrial origin (fire, explosion, toxic leak) whose serious immediate consequences spill over onto staff, neighbours, property and the environment. Fire and release of dangerous substances are by far the most frequent events. Operating risk (breakdowns, shutdowns, limited accidents) is much more frequent than major risk: see lesson 1-5.