Aurorisk FR

Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.2

Business IT and industrial IT

The principles of IT security also apply in industry, but their order of priority and their means change. Ignoring these differences is the first cause of project failure.

What changes

Business IT (IT)Industrial IT (OT)
PriorityConfidentiality, then integrity, then availabilityAvailability and integrity of the process first, then confidentiality
Consequence of a failureData loss, a service stopsDanger to people, pollution, lost production, equipment damage
LifetimeA few yearsOften 15 to 30 years
UpdatesRegular, automaticRare: a production stop to plan, validation by the manufacturer
Response timeA delay is toleratedReal time: a delay can degrade the control
ProtocolsInternet standardsIndustrial protocols often designed without authentication (Modbus for example)
CounterpartsInformation systems departmentAutomation engineers, operators, reliability and safety engineers
Security priorities compared: business IT and industrial ITTwo columns. Business IT: confidentiality, then integrity, then availability; lifetime of a few years; regular updates. Industrial IT: availability, then integrity, then confidentiality; lifetime of 15 to 30 years; rare, planned updates.Business IT (IT)Industrial IT (OT)1 Confidentialitydata does not leak1 Availabilitythe process must not stop2 Integritydata is correct2 Integritycommands and values are correct3 Availabilitythe service comes back quickly3 Confidentialityimportant, but after the restLifetime: a few yearsLifetime: 15 to 30 yearsRegular, automatic updatesRare updates, shutdown to plan
The order of priorities is reversed: a scan or a restart that is harmless in business IT can freeze a PLC.

Practical consequences

Caution

Availability comes first, but that is no licence to protect nothing: a system open to the Internet, without segmentation, ends up stopping, and it is then availability that is lost.

Common mistake

Applying business IT reflexes to the shop floor: a network scan, a restart or an unqualified patch can stop the process.

Key takeaway

We keep the objectives of business IT (confidentiality, integrity, availability) but rank them differently and adapt the measures to the constraints of real time, longevity and safety.