Aurorisk FR

Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.3

Three modes of use: before, during, after the session

AI can be brought in at three moments. Each has its advantages and risks, and they are not mutually exclusive.

Three moments to bring in AIThe HAZOP session: Before; During; AfterThe HAZOP sessionBeforefirst draft;anchoring riskDuringprompting, notes;risk ofdistractionAftercompletenessreview;false senseof coverage
Common compromise: a session without a prior proposal, then an AI review and a comparison.
ModePrincipleAdvantagesRisks
Before the sessionThe facilitator or an engineer has a first draft of deviations, causes and consequences generated, reads it and prepares itTime saved in the session; exhaustive starting list; help for a novice facilitatorAnchoring bias : the team is content to validate what is written instead of searching
During the sessionAn assistant runs during the session and suggests ideas when the team runs dry, or takes notesPrompts the team’s thinking; faster minutesDistraction; the screen takes over from the discussion; live confidentiality
After the sessionThe table is reviewed: omissions, inconsistencies, wording, then the report is writtenNo effect on the team’s thinking; detects omissionsFalse sense of coverage; text changes that alter the meaning
A common compromise

Hold the session without a prior proposal, then ask the AI for a completeness review and compare. You keep the team’s creative effect and you recover the omissions. The course studies the comparison in chapter 4, and the debate on anchoring in chapter 6.

This split is a working framework of the course, not a standardised practice.