Aurorisk FR

Chapter 1 · Lesson 1.4

Choosing a model

There is no universal model. The right choice depends on what you are looking for, the size of the system and the person who will have to read the result.

Three questions for choosing

  1. How big is the system? Up to a few components, the Markov chain can be built by hand and checked. Beyond about ten interacting components, the number of states becomes unmanageable.
  2. Do you want an exact result or an estimate? For a regulatory decision or an inspection, an exact result is valuable. To explore a large model, an estimate with a confidence interval is enough.
  3. Who has to read the model? A fault tree can be read without training. A Markov graph of forty states cannot. A well-structured Petri net reads like a diagram of how the system works.

Practical rules

The loading bay

Question askedModel chosenReason
Availability of the two pumpsThree-state MarkovSmall system, exact result, figure checkable by hand
Periodically tested shutdown functionMarkov (or formula validated by Markov)No repair between tests: the calculation can be done by hand
Loading sequence and hidden failuresPetri netOrder of events, “detector failed undetected” state
Cascade to the neighbouring bayEvent tree then PetriBarriers that act or not before propagation
Complete modelGlobal Petri, simulation, sub-parts reduced to MarkovToo many states for a single chain
Key takeaway

The choice of model is made on the size of the system, the need for an exact or estimated result and readability for the team. Start with the simplest, add complexity where the dynamics matter, and keep a simple model to check the richer one.